#FactCheck: Old Video from Jammu’s Maharaja Hari Singh Birth Anniversary Procession Falsely Linked to CJP’s Proposed Protest at Jantar Mantar
Executive Summary
The Cockroach Janata Party (CJP) has called for a protest against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and a “Chalo Delhi” campaign at Jantar Mantar in New Delhi on Saturday, October 10. Meanwhile, a video is being widely shared on social media showing a large number of people carrying saffron flags and walking on a road. The video is being shared with the claim that the people seen in it are members of Hindu organisations marching towards Jantar Mantar in large numbers to oppose the CJP’s proposed protest. CyberPeace Research found that the viral video is old and shows a procession held at Dogra Chowk in Jammu on the occasion of Maharaja Hari Singh’s birth anniversary.
Claim
A Facebook user shared the viral video with the caption,“News is coming that Hindu organisations have started a movement called the ‘Catch Cockroach Campaign’. Yes, they have given the campaign this name. A large number of people from Hindu organisations are leaving for Jantar Mantar. Brother Deepak... my free advice is... leave for America, because these are very ‘cruel people’ who can change 500 years of history in five hours... Jai Bhawani, Jai Shivaji, now it’s your turn.”The post link, archive link and screenshot are provided below.
https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=1660133012350967&set=a.536762061354740
Fact Check
To verify the claim, we first conducted a reverse image search of a frame from the viral video using Google Lens. Through this search, we found the same video posted on an Instagram page named Rana Ashish Singh on February 21, 2023. However, the post did not provide any information that could help verify the actual origin or context of the video.
https://www.instagram.com/reels/Co61z_zMQr6/
In our further research, we found a higher-quality version of the viral video on the Instagram account ‘@anilgiri4659’, posted in February 2023. On closely analysing the video, we noticed the words “Jai Chandi Maa” written on one of the vehicles, while the number plate of another black vehicle displayed “JK” followed by some digits. We also noticed “Baker’s Avenue” written on the roof of a shop, with a signboard next to it bearing the words “Sport Music” in red. A white building with some black designs painted on it was also visible on the left side of the video. Further into the video, a red-coloured building could be seen. Based on these visual clues, we suspected that the video could be from Jammu and Kashmir.
https://www.instagram.com/reels/CpKOrGkv6SV/
Using these clues, we carried out a geolocation analysis to identify the location and road visible in the viral video. Our research found that the location shown in the viral video is Dogra Chowk in Prem Nagar, Jammu. To further verify this, a comparative analysis of the visuals from the viral video and the corresponding location can be seen in the graphics below.
We also found a clarification issued by the official X account of Bajrang Dal regarding the claim that its workers would gather at Jantar Mantar. The post also described the viral claim as misleading and clarified that there is no such plan from Bajrang Dal.
https://x.com/BajrangDalOrg/status/2108059565753536897
Conclusion
CyberPeace Research found that the viral video does not show a protest against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar in Delhi. Instead, it shows a procession at Dogra Chowk in Prem Nagar, Jammu, held in September 2022 on the occasion of Maharaja Hari Singh’s birth anniversary. Therefore, the claim that members of Hindu organisations are marching towards Jantar Mantar to oppose the CJP’s proposed protest is misleading.
Related Blogs
Introduction
As the world seemingly shrinks under the vast, ever-stretching canopy of the internet, the channels through which information flows are becoming increasingly enigmatic and tangled. In the digital world, the gulf between fact and fabrication narrows dramatically, with the veracity of information too often lost in the flood. Amidst the torrents of data, platforms like YouTube, a veritable Goliath in the video streaming sphere, are finding themselves at the forefront of a critical battle against the dark forces of fake news and disinformation—a war that is waged with the intensity of any historical conflict over truth and influence.
It is in this volatile theatre that Google's video behemoth, YouTube, under the scrutiny of the global eye, announces its strategic campaign to shield against the onslaught of misinformation. With India, the world's most populous democracy, on the cusp of its monumental general elections, the stakes could hardly be higher. YouTube's involvement thus evolves beyond corporate social responsibility—it becomes a crusade for the integrity of information, a paladin for the democratic process, and a protector of the public’s right to factual reporting.
The Campaign
The campaign envisioned by YouTube India's vanguard is multifaceted and robust, aimed at rooting out the insidious tendrils of fake news where they lie. At the heart of this mission are two pivotal strategies that form the backbone of YouTube's defense. Firstly, a rigorous misinformation policy, which heralds as a bastion against content designed with duplicitous intent. YouTube Indian Head Ishan Chatterjee elucidates, 'Our misinformation policies clearly state that if the content has been technically manipulated with the intent to deceive a user and there's a danger of real-world harm...we will act against that content.' It is an exhortation of YouTube's commitment to a culture of truth and an acknowledgement of the platform's influence and responsibility. This process, however, is more complex than it appears; it is tangled in socio-political nuances and demands an uncompromising vigilance to identify and dispel falsehoods.
Yet, this is merely the foundation upon which YouTube’s strategy rests. The second prong of their stratagem is even more ambitious—intending not only to eradicate the chaff of misinformation but also to till the soil with the seeds of verifiable, authoritative news content. This is an initiative to resuscitate the public's faith in digital information sources. By allying with credible news publishers and fostering a symbiosis with independent journalists, YouTube has taken up the mantle of an institution that not just police content, but cultivates it, transforming the barren desert of online falsehoods into an oasis of enlightenment.
News on YouTube is symbiotic with the larger consciousness of its users, driving content consumption and engaging millions who seek out current affairs, investigative reports, and in-depth analysis on the platform. The democratisation of news, once the hallowed ground of traditional broadcast and print media, now finds its theatre online. Chatterjee insightfully notes the ascending trend of news story engagement on YouTube Shorts and Connected TV (CTV)—two emergent platforms that have revolutionised content delivery and consumption. CTV, in particular, has skyrocketed in popularity within the past five years, boasting over 58 million viewers in India consuming YouTube content from the comfort of their living rooms as of June 2023, per analytics.
This phenomenon is acutely observed by YouTube's Director and Global Head of Responsibility, Tim Katz, who delineates a portrait of the Indian market's distinctive hunger for live content, particularly news, on CTV. Katz's observations carry an air of fascination, 'The other two things that have been exciting to see are that we've seen a lot of growth, particularly during sensitive moments, with large news stories occurring certainly during an election cycle, and we just see very large growth from many of our authoritative partners.'
The Implications of the Campaign
The tapestry of YouTube's news ecosystem is a rich mosaic of diversity, including independent journalists, broadcasters, legacy print publications, and digital-first media organisations. Katz underscores the gravity of nurturing such a broad and dynamic news environment on the platform, a gesture of YouTube's commitment to a holistic information landscape.
An illuminating report from the Google News Initiative, forged in cooperation with Kantar, reiterates the dominance of video as the consummate medium for news consumption across a spectrum of languages and formats in India. It paints a picture of a nation of insatiable news consumers, with nearly every second Indian language internet user engaging with news content, a substantial proportion hailing from urban locales. Of particular resonance is hyperlocal news, which plucks the chords of local interests and concerns, touching the lives of seven out of ten citizens.
Moreover, the economic impetus behind YouTube’s role in the media firmament is brought to light in the Oxford Economics Impact Report, revealing a staggering 70% of Indian media and music companies with a YouTube presence acknowledge the platform as a crucial revenue stream.
Conclusion
Poised upon the sharp edge of an electric election season—a season that will no doubt be drenched in a spectrum of information, both fact and fable—YouTube's convictions stand as a beacon of reliability. Their initiative is more than a method—it's a philosophy, a dedication to purifying the information sphere. In the digital epoch, where the battle lines for truth are drawn in bytes and bandwidth, YouTube’s rallying cry for responsibility, its vow to safeguard democratic ideals, and its unyielding commitment to illuminating the corridors of knowledge are more than strategies; they are pillars on which a well-informed, engaged, and enlightened citizenry can lean.
Reference
Introduction
Freedom of speech and expression is fundamental to democracy and is constitutionally entrenched in Article 19(1)(a) of the Indian Constitution. The explosion of online spaces, brought about by the digital age, in the form of social media, blogs, and messaging apps, has reinterpreted how information is authored, disseminated, and consumed. This digital revolution has galvanised individuals to engage further inclusively in public debate, but has also fanatically magnified the risks of misinformation, hate speech, and threats to public order. Against this background, the judiciary is increasingly called upon to determine the limits of free speech, primarily where state regulation seeks to infringe upon constitutional protection.
Constitutional and Statutory Framework related to Freedom of Speech
The judiciary plays an integral role in balancing the fundamental right of freedom of speech with the regulation of online content, especially during the fast-paced evolution of the digital world. In India, with Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution guaranteeing the freedom of speech, the courts bear the critical responsibility of protecting this liberty while recognising the State's legitimate interests in restricting harmful or unlawful content on a digital scale. This adjudicatory dilemma is even trickier because the said right has been held by the Supreme Court not to be an absolute one and is subject to "reasonable restrictions" as in Article 19(2), which recognises restrictions in the interest of sovereignty, security, public order, decency, and morality. Freedom of speech, being the cornerstone of democracy in India, does have an umbrella of reasonable restrictions under which the state can regulate any form of speech that infringes upon other equally compelling societal interests. However, with the coming of the internet and other digital communication arrangements, there was a need to develop new statutory instruments, i.e., Information Technology Act, 2000 (IT Act) and Rules made thereunder, including Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines) and Digital Media Ethics Code Rules, 2021. These enactments attempt to regulate digital content, confronting issues such as hate speech, misinformation, and content that threatens public order. The judiciary's mandate is to interpret the enactments within the constitutional precincts, thus ensuring that the arbitrariness of State action is not aggravated or that the regulation is not overbroad. Judicial Landmark Decisions Affirming Balance The judiciary has played a front-ranking role in elaborating a jurisprudence protecting free speech in delineating legitimate regulation thereof. The Supreme Court judgment in Shreya Singhal v. Union of India, 2015, is seminal. Section 66A of the IT Act was struck down as it was vague and overly broad, causing a chilling effect on online speech. The Court has emphasised that any limitation on speech must be precise and fall strictly within the parameters laid down in Article 19(2). While the Court recognises that harmful online content needs to be addressed, the remedy must not encroach upon free political debate, satire, and criticism vital for democracy.
Following this, the Anuradha Bhasin case clarified the convergence of free speech and online access. The court held that the right to free speech had a vital medium in the form of the internet and that it would have to be an inevitable, proportionate shutdown, and transparent for challenge before the judiciary for any shutdown of the internet. This reaffirmed that restrictions on online speech must be rigorously tested.
Subsequent cases involve limitations on the 2021 IT Rules, whereby such government bodies can demand that “fake” or “misleading” material be taken off the internet. Courts move with circumspection, recognising the government's interest in fighting bogus information but remaining vigilant against over-regulation that can be code for pre-emptive censorship and threatening healthy discourses.
The virtual world raises particular and deeper questions: the viral nature of online speech multiplies its impact, distributing both democratic ideas and abusive material instantaneously. The courts recognise this twinning. While pressurising the legislature and executive to formulate clearer, more precise rules, courts simultaneously act as constitutional Guardians, avoiding breaches of the right with executive excess or vague laws. There is a strain between judicial activism, which promotes constitutional rights aggressively, and the fear of judicial paternalism, courts overreaching into policy arenas. But there is a need for vigilance by the judiciary due to the rapidly changing nature of digital technologies and threats to the freedoms of democracy. The judiciary continues to give contours to free speech and online regulation. There are enforcement issues, such as ongoing abuse of struck-down provisions, such as Section 66A, that the court counters with reaffirmation of constitutional directives. The evolving jurisprudence balances on thin stilts, upholding the democratic spirit of India by securing speech on online spaces and sanctioning reasonable, transparent moderation of harmful speech.
Conclusion
The Indian judiciary's leadership in balancing online content regulation with the freedom of speech is central and refined. The courts continually emphasise that speech on the digital medium is highly constitutionally protected and that restrictions must be legally valid, specific, essential, and proportionate. By classical decisions and constant review of new regulating actions, courts safeguard democratic participation in the digital public domain from unmeritorious censorship. Concurrently, the courts recognize the responsibility of the state in regulating digital ills such as mis recipe and hate speech, demanding parameters that uphold constitutional freedoms and the due process. The balancing act of the judiciary continues to be fundamental in defining India's digital democracy so that free speech can thrive even as the state upholds public order and human dignity in the digital communication age.
Overview of the India-UK Joint Tech Security Initiative
India and the UK have been deepening their technological and security ties through various initiatives and agreements. One of the key developments in this partnership is the India-UK Joint Tech Security Initiative, which focuses on enhancing collaboration in areas like cybersecurity, artificial intelligence (AI),telecommunications, and critical technologies. Building upon the bilateral cooperation agenda set out in the India-UK Roadmap 2030, which seeks to bolster cooperation across various sectors, including trade, climate change, antidefense, the UK and India launched the Joint Tech Security Initiative (TSI) on July 24, 2024. This initiative will priorities collaboration in critical and emerging technologies across priority sectors. Coordinating with the national security agencies of both countries, the TSI will set priority areas and identify interdependencies for cooperation on critical and emerging technologies. This, in turn, will help build meaningful technology value chain partnerships between India & the UK.
The TSI will be coordinated by the National Security Advisors (NSAs) of both countries through existing and new dialogues. The NSAswill set priority areas and identify interdependencies for cooperation on critical and emerging tech, helping build meaningful technology value chain partnerships between the two countries. Progress made on the initiative will be reviewed on a half-yearly basis at the Deputy NSA level. A bilateral mechanism will be established led by India's Ministry of External Affairs and the UK government for promotion of trade in critical and emerging technologies, including resolution of relevant licensing or regulatory issues. Both countries view this TSI as a platform and a strong signal of intent to build and grow sustainable and tangible partnerships across priority tech sectors. They will explore how to build a deeper strategic partnership between UK and Indian research and technology centres and Incubators, enhance cooperation across UK and India tech and innovation ecosystems, and create a channel for industry and academia to help shape the TSI.
The UK and India are launching new bilateral initiatives to expand and deepen their technology security partnership. These initiatives will focus on various domains, including telecoms, critical minerals, semiconductors, and energy security.
In telecoms, the UK and India will build a new Future Telecoms Partnership, focusing on joint research on future telecoms, open RAN systems, testbed linkups, telecoms security, spectrum innovation, software and systems architecture. This will include collaboration between UK's SONIC Labs, India's Centre for Development of Telematics (C-DOT), and Dot's Telecoms Startup Mission.
In critical minerals, the UK and India will expand their collaboration on critical minerals, working together to improve supply chain resilience, explore possible research and development and technology partnerships along the complete critical minerals value chain, and share best practices on ESG standards. They will establish a roadmap for cooperation and establish a UK-India ‘critical minerals’ community of academics, innovators, and industry.
Key Areas of Collaboration:
- Strengthening cybersecurity defense and enhancing resilience through joint cybersecurity exercises and information-sharing and developing common standards and best practices while collaborating with their respective organisations, ie, CERT-In and NCSC.
- Promotion of ethical AI development and deployment with AI ethics guidelines and frameworks, and efforts encouraging academic collaborations. Support for new partnerships between UK and Indian research organizations alongside existing joint programmes using AI to tackle global challenges.
- Building secure and resilient telecom infrastructure with a focus on security and exchange of expertise and regulatory cooperation. Collaboration on Open Radio Access Networks tech to name as an example.
- Critical and emerging technologies development by advancing research and innovation in the quantum, semiconductors and biotechnology niches. Promoting and investing in tech startups and innovation ecosystems. Engaging in policy dialogues on tech governance and standards.
- Digital economy and trade facilitation to promote economic growth by enhancing frameworks and agreements for it. Collaborating on digital payment systems and fintech solutions and most importantly promoting data protection and privacy standards.
Outlook and Impact on the Industry
The initiative sets out a new approach for how the UK and India work together on the defining technologies of this decade. These include areas such as telecoms, critical minerals, AI, quantum, health/biotechnology, advanced materials and semiconductors. While the initiative looks promising, several challenges need to be addressed such as the need to put robust regulatory frameworks in place, and develop a balanced approach for data privacy and information exchange in the cross-border data flows. It is imperative to install mechanisms that ensure that intellectual property is protected while the facilitation of technology transfer is not hampered. Above all, geopolitical risks need to be navigated in a manner that the tensions are reduced and a stable partnership grows. The Initiative builds on a series of partnerships between India and the UK, as well as between industry and academia. Abilateral mechanism, led by India’s Ministry of External Affairs and the UK government, will promote trade in critical and emerging technologies, including the resolution of relevant licensing or regulatory issues.
Conclusion
This initiative, at its core, will drive forward a bilateral partnership that is framed on boosting economic growth and deepening cooperation across key issues including trade, technology, education, culture and climate. By combining their strengths, the UK and India are poised to create a robust framework for technological innovation and security that could serve as a model for international cooperation in tech.
References
- https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/india-uk-launch-joint-tech-security-initiative-101721876539784.html
- https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/uk-india-technology-security-initiative-factsheet/uk-india-technology-security-initiative-factsheet
- https://www.business-standard.com/economy/news/india-uk-unveil-futuristic-technology-security-initiative-to-seal-fta-soon-124072500014_1.htm
- https://bharatshakti.in/india-uk-technology-security-initiative/
