#FactCheck-India Passport Ranking Claim Comparing 2014 and 2026 Rankings Is Misleading

Introduction

Attacks by cybercriminals targeting national critical infrastructure are increasing at an unsettling rate. Such attacks have the potential to do severe damage by upsetting transportation networks, utilities, financial services, and other vital infrastructure. The physical and digital systems that underpin a nation's economy are known as critical infrastructure thus if they were to be disrupted, there would be serious risks to the economy and public health and safety. Establishing proper cybersecurity measures and protecting those digital systems from possible threats or cyberattacks is necessary. Both public and private sector assets are included in these essential infrastructure categories.

Nationwide alert:

Recently one of the biggest hacker organizations has warned of an upcoming cyberattack on the critical infrastructure and websites in India, causing a countrywide alert. A gang of hackers from Indonesia and Pakistan, celebrating 4,000 members, announced a planned “Cyber Party” on 11 December 2023. The event’s claimed goal is to compromise and disrupt India's digital infrastructure. They disclosed this information on their Telegram channel.

This hacker organization holds a record of launching extensive cyberattacks; in the past, it sent out a "red notice" that was intended to target 12,000 websites run by the Indian government. They have previously attacked other nations, such as Israel, Sweden, and the United States. Their reasons are varied and might include anything from assaults on certain groups to religious disagreements.

The gang has also been acclaimed for hacking into a New York City police agency, obtaining health and social media data from Israel, and exposing information from Swedish social media users. These alarming events show how urgently strong and all-encompassing cybersecurity measures are needed, not only in India but throughout the world.

Effect(s) on India

1.  Central Agencies Are Alert, Expect Health Sector Attacks: The cyberinfrastructure of the health sector has been a common target of assaults, particularly in the aftermath of the COVID-19 epidemic, which has authorities particularly concerned. Relevant ministries have received notifications from central authorities advising them to take precautions against unwanted access. The security of digital infrastructure is seriously challenged by the constantly changing panorama of cyber-attacks, according to those who are aware of the warning and threat.

2. National security concerns: Because of the interconnectedness of critical national infrastructure, a cyberattack may have an impact on national security. Attacks against defense networks, intelligence organizations health infrastructure, or military systems, for instance, might make it more difficult for the nation to respond to threats from outside.

3.    Concerns for Public Safety and Health: Cyberattacks on healthcare systems run the risk of compromising patient data, stopping medical procedures, and even endangering the general public's health. This might have potentially fatal results in urgent circumstances.

4.  Data Breach and Privacy Issues: Stealing confidential data is a common component of cybersecurity assaults. A breach of critical infrastructure systems might result in sensitive data, including personal information, being misused and accessed without authorization, raising privacy issues.

Preventive and protective measures

1.    The plan for responding to incidents: Make sure a clear incident response strategy is in place, with a focus on healthcare systems, and that it is especially designed to handle cyber-attacks on critical infrastructure.

2.  Better Tracking: Observing vital networks, systems, and data flows more closely, especially in the healthcare industry. Using cutting-edge threat detection technologies to spot odd or questionable activity.

3.   Critical System Isolation: Cutting off vital healthcare systems from the wider network to reduce the chance of attackers moving laterally.

4.   Continual Backups: Make sure that backup copies of important data and systems are kept in a safe, isolated location by regularly backing them up. In the event of a ransomware attack or data breach, this makes recovery easier.

5.    Update and patch systems: Make sure that all operating systems and apps utilized in the infrastructure of the healthcare industry are updated with the most recent security updates.

6. Protocols for Communication: In the case of a cyber-incident, establishing explicit communication mechanisms to guarantee that pertinent parties are notified as soon as possible. This covers correspondence with law enforcement, the public, and other members of the healthcare industry as needed.

Conclusion

Urgent preventative actions are essential in response to an impending cyber threat revealed by a large hacker organization that is targeting India's key infrastructure, specifically the healthcare sector. The interconnectedness of this infrastructure puts public safety, privacy, and national security in danger. A crucial defensive approach is formed by the proactive measures mentioned, which include communication protocols, system isolation, improved monitoring, incident response preparation, and frequent backups. The dangers underline the necessity of international collaboration in tackling cybersecurity issues and the requirement for shared responsibility of everyone to safeguard digital networks. To reduce risks and guarantee the resilience of vital national infrastructure in the face of changing cyber threats, authorities must continue to develop and adapt their cybersecurity tactics.

References:

• https://www.cnbctv18.com/technology/exclusive--nationwide-alert-sounded-as-hacker-group-plans-cyber-party-to-attack-indias-critical-digital-infra-18520021.htm
• https://www.the420.in/ndian-authorities-high-alert-hacker-groups-threaten-cyber-assault/
• https://www.cnbctv18.com/technology/exclusive--nationwide-alert-sounded-as-hacker-group-plans-cyber-party-to-attack-indias-critical-digital-infra-18520021.htm#:~:text=By%20News18.com%20Dec%208,%3A58%20AM%20IST%20(Published)&text=A%20nationwide%20alert%20has%20been,Indian%20websites%20and%20critical%20infrastructure
• https://verveindustrial.com/resources/blog/critical-infrastructure-cyber-security/

Introduction

In a setback to the Centre, the Bombay High Court on Friday 20th September 2024, struck down the provisions under IT Amendment Rules 2023, which empowered the Central Government to establish Fact Check Units (FCUs) to identify ‘fake and misleading’ information about its business on social media platforms. 

Chronological Overview

• On 6th April 2023, the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) notified the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Amendment Rules, 2023 (IT Amendment Rules, 2023). These rules introduced new provisions to establish a fact-checking unit with respect to “any business of the central government”. This amendment was done In exercise of the powers conferred by section 87 of the Information Technology Act, 2000. (IT Act).
• On 20 March 2024, the Central Government notified the Press Information Bureau (PIB) as FCU under rule 3(1)(b)(v) of the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Amendment Rules 2023 (IT Amendment Rules 2023). 
• The next day on  21st March 2024, the Supreme Court stayed the Centre's decision on notifying PIB -FCU, considering the pendency of the proceedings before the High Court of Judicature at Bombay. A detailed analysis covered by CyberPeace on the Supreme Court Stay decision can be accessed here.
• In the latest development, the Bombay High Court on 20th September 2024, struck down the provisions under IT Amendment Rules 2023, which empowered the Central Government to establish Fact Check Units (FCUs) to identify ‘fake and misleading’ information about its business on social media platforms.  

Brief Overview of Bombay High Court decision dated 20th September 2024

Justice AS Chandurkar was appointed as the third judge after a split verdict in January 2023 by a division bench consisting of Justices Gautam Patel and Neela Gokhal.  As a Tie-breaker judge' Justice AS Chandurkar delivered the decision striking down provisions for setting up a Fact Check Unit under IT amendment 2023 rules. Striking down the Centre's proposed fact check unit provision, Justice A S Chandurkar of Bombay High Court also opined that there was no rationale to undertake an exercise in determining whether information related to the business of the Central govt was fake or false or misleading when in digital form but not doing the same when such information was in print. It was also contended that there is no justification to introduce an FCU only in relation to the business of the Central Government. Rule 3(1)(b)(v) has a serious chilling effect on the exercise of the freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution since the communication of the view of the FCU will result in the intermediary simply pulling down the content for fear of consequences or losing the safe harbour provision given under IT Act.  

Justice Chandurkar held that the expressions ‘fake, false or misleading’ are ‘vague and overbroad’, and that the ‘test of proportionality’ is not satisfied. Rule 3(1)(b)(v), was violative of Articles 14 and 19 (1) (a) and 19 (1) (g) of the Constitution and it is “ultra vires”, or beyond the powers, of the IT Act.

Role of Expert Organisations in Curbing Mis/Disinformation and Fake News

In light of the recent developments, and the rising incidents of Mis/Disinformation and Fake News it becomes significantly important that we all stand together in the fight against these challenges. The actions against Mis/Disinformation and fake news should be strengthened by collective efforts, the expert organisations like CyberPeace Foundation plays an key role in enabling and encouraging netizens to exercise caution and rely on authenticated sources, rather than solely rely on govt FCU to block the content. 

Mis/Disinformation and Fake News should be stopped, identified and countered by netizens at the very first stage of its spread. In light of the Bombay High Court's decision to stuck down the provision related to setting up the FCU by the Central Government, it entails that the government's intention to address misinformation related solely to its business/operations may not have been effectively communicated in the eyes of the judiciary.

It is high time to exercise collective efforts against Mis/Disinformation and Fake News and support expert organizations who are actively engaged in conducting proactive measures, and campaigns to target these challenges, specifically in the online information landscape. CyberPeace actively publishes fact-checking reports and insights on Prebunking and Debunking, conducts expert sessions and takes various key steps aimed at empowering netizens to build cognitive defences to recognise the susceptible information, disregard misleading claims and prevent further spreads to ensure the true online information landscape.

References:

• https://www.scconline.com/blog/post/2024/09/20/bombay-high-court-it-rules-amendment-2023-fact-check-units-article14-article19-legal-news/#:~:text=Bombay%20High%20Court%3A%20A%20case,grounds%20that%20it%20violated%20constitutional
• https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/mumbai/bombay-hc-strikes-down-it-act-amendment-fact-check-unit-9579044/
• https://www.cyberpeace.org/resources/blogs/supreme-court-stay-on-centres-notification-of-pibs-fact-check-unit-under-it-amendment-rules-2023

‍

Executive Summary

‍
A video is being widely shared on social media claiming to show baggage handlers in India carelessly unloading passenger luggage from an aircraft cargo hold. The clip allegedly shows a handler ignoring standard procedures and throwing bags directly onto the tarmac instead of placing them on a motorized conveyor belt. CyberPeace Research Wing research  found the video to be entirely fake. The clip has been generated using artificial intelligence (AI) and is being falsely shared as a real incident from India.

‍

Claim

‍

An X user, I.P. Singh (@IPSinghSp), shared the video on June 25, claiming it shows baggage handlers unloading luggage from an aircraft in India. The post criticized the alleged mishandling of passenger baggage and questioned aviation authorities over poor service standards.

The accompanying post read:

“When will the DGCA and the Civil Aviation Minister finally pay attention? Despite high airfares, this is the state of passengers’ luggage. The Ministry of Civil Aviation should learn from Japan and China how luggage should be handled.” https://x.com/IPSinghSp/status/2070164107551273109?s=20 , https://archive.ph/heiHA

‍

‍

Fact Check

‍

A detailed analysis of the footage revealed multiple visual inconsistencies suggesting AI generation. Notably, even after the baggage handler seen initially tossing the luggage exits via the conveyor belt, bags continue to emerge from the cargo hold and fall onto the tarmac on their own.  This physically impossible sequence strongly indicates digital manipulation. To verify these findings, the video was analyzed using the AI detection tool Hive Moderation. The results indicated that a significant portion of the footage was generated using artificial intelligence.

‍

‍

‍

Conclusion

‍

Our research  confirms that the viral video is entirely fake. It has been generated using AI and is being misrepresented as a real incident from India involving baggage handling at an airport.

‍