#FactCheck - Viral Video of Man ‘Running on Water’ Found to Be AI-Generated

Introduction

In the digital entertainment world, OTT platforms have become highly popular and have attracted larger audiences. They offer a wide variety of entertaining content. However, there are certain concerns about depicting illicit or objectionable content on such platforms. The Indian Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (I&B) has been working on tackling issues like the availability of obscene content on online streaming platforms and other platforms. I&B Ministry has taken important steps to prevent the spread of such illicit or objectionable content.

The I&B Ministry has taken action against obscene and vulgar content on OTT platforms. A total 18 OTT platforms and several associated websites, apps, and social media handles have been blocked nationwide. The government has been in consistent talks with these platforms and issued several advisories, but they have not been adhered to. The decision was made after consultation with other ministries, domain experts, and industry bodies. The content allegedly obscene was found to depict nudity, sexual intercourse, and inappropriate sexual acts within societal contexts. The government states that it is the responsibility of platforms to ensure that content is not present in a vulgar fashion. Creativities do not necessarily mean promoting or propagating vulgar and sexual content.

Key Highlights of I&B Ministry Action against Obscene Content

On 14th March 2024, The Indian Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (I&B) announced the blocking of 18 OTT platforms, 19 Websites, 10 apps, and 57 social media handles for displaying obscene and vulgar content. Union Minister for Information & Broadcasting Shri Anurag Singh Thakur has announced the removal of 18 OTT platforms that published obscene and vulgar content, underscoring the responsibility of platforms to prevent the spread of such content. The decision was made under the Information Technology Act 2000 and in consultation with other Indian ministries and domain experts in media, entertainment, women's rights, and child rights.

List of Blocked OTT Platforms

OTT platforms that have been blocked are Dreams Films, Voovi, Yessma, Uncut Adda, Tri Flicks, X Prime, Neon X VIP, Besharams, Hunters, Rabbit, Xtramood, Nuefliks, MoodX, Mojflix, Hot Shots VIP, Fugi, Chikooflix, Prime Play.

It was highlighted that these OTT platforms, despite not being widely popular, have a significant viewership. One app has over 1 crore downloads, while two others have more than 50 lakh downloads on Google Play Store. These platforms also market their content through social media, with a combined followership of over 32 lakh.

Nature of content

The ministry reported that a significant portion of the content on social media platforms was obscene, vulgar, and demeaning, depicting nudity and sexual acts in inappropriate contexts like teacher-student relationships and incestuous family relationships. The content included sexual innuendos and prolonged pornographic scenes without any thematic or societal relevance. It was further stated that the content was found to be prima facie in violation of Section 67 and 67A of the Information & Technology Act, 2000, Section 292 of the Indian Penal Code and  Section 4 of the Indecent Representation of Women (Prohibition) Act, 1986.

Way Forward

The press release by the ministry stated that “The Government of India remains committed to fostering the growth and development of the OTT industry. Several measures have been undertaken in this regard, including the introduction of the Inaugural OTT Award for Web Series at the 54th International Film Festival of India, collaboration with OTT platforms in the media and entertainment sector, and the establishment of a light touch regulatory framework with an emphasis on self-regulation under the IT Rules, 2021.”

This shows that the Indian government is dedicated to promoting the growth of the OTT industry but within certain checks or oversight mechanisms to prevent illicit or objectionable content on such platforms.

OTT Content and Regulatory Checks

Online content streaming on OTT platforms lacks regulatory checks, unlike films, which are reviewed and certified by a government-appointed board. The government has instructed streaming services to independently review content for obscenity and violence before it is made available online. There have been repeated instances where criticism has been raised about the illicit or violative depicted content in some OTT shows. This highlights the issue of checks and balances. The government has urged self-regulation on platforms, but the repeated instances of illicit content raise societal concerns. The Ministry of I&B is keen towards promoting ethical & moral standards of content that is being hosted on online OTT platforms.

Conclusion

The Ministry of I&B has taken a step and announced the shutdown of 18 OTT platforms that were engaged in depicting illicit content. This shows that the I&B Ministry is committed to promoting ethical online content. While legislative measures are required to prevent the spread of such illicit or violative content, joint efforts by the government, industry players, and civil society are critical to ensuring a secure and responsible digital environment for all users.

References

• https://pib.gov.in/PressReleaseIframePage.aspx?PRID=2014477
• https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/centre-bans-ott-platforms-websites-and-apps-over-obscene-and-vulgar-content/article67949819.ece
• https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/ib-ministry-blocks-18-ott-platforms-for-vulgar-content/articleshow/108485880.cms?from=mdr
• https://indianexpress.com/article/entertainment/information-and-broadcasting-ministry-blocks-18-ott-platforms-for-obscene-and-vulgar-content-9213749/
• https://www.storyboard18.com/ott-news/mib-blocks-18-ott-platforms-for-showing-obscene-and-vulgar-content-26400.htm

‍

Introduction

The recent events in Mira Road, a bustling suburb on the outskirts of Mumbai, India, unfold like a modern-day parable, cautioning us against the perils of unverified digital content. The Mira Road incident, a communal clash that erupted into the physical realm, has been mirrored and magnified through the prism of social media. The Maharashtra Police, in a concerted effort to quell the spread of discord, issued stern warnings against the dissemination of rumours and fake messages. These digital phantoms, they stressed, have the potential to ignite law and order conflagrations, threatening the delicate tapestry of peace.

The police's clarion call came in the wake of a video, mischievously edited, that falsely claimed anti-social elements had set the Mira Road railway station ablaze. This digital doppelgänger of reality swiftly went viral, its tendrils reaching into the ubiquitous realm of WhatsApp, ensnaring the unsuspecting in its web of deceit.

In this age of information overload, where the line between fact and fabrication blurs, the police urged citizens to exercise discernment. The note they issued was not merely an advisory but a plea for vigilance, a reminder that the act of sharing unauthenticated messages is not a passive one; it is an act that can disturb the peace and unravel the fabric of society.

The Massacre 

The police's response to this crisis was multifaceted. Administrators and members of social media groups found to be the harbingers of such falsehoods would face legal repercussions. The Thane District, a mosaic of cultural and religious significance, has been marred by a series of violent incidents, casting a shadow over its storied history. The police, in their role as guardians of order, have detained individuals, scoured social media for inauthentic posts, and maintained a vigilant presence in the region.

The Maharashtra cyber cell, a digital sentinel, has unearthed approximately 15 posts laden with videos and messages designed to sow discord among the masses. These findings were shared with the Mira-Bhayandar, Vasai-Virar (MBVV) police, who stand ready to take appropriate action. Inspector General Yashasvi Yadav of the Maharashtra cyber cell issued an appeal to the public, urging them to refrain from circulating such unverified messages, reinforcing the notion that the propagation of inauthentic information is, in itself, a crime.

The MBVV police, in their zero-tolerance stance, have formed a team dedicated to scrutinizing social media posts. The message is clear: fake news will be met with strict action. The right to free speech on social media comes with the responsibility not to share information that could incite mischief. The Indian Penal Code and Information Technology Act serve as the bulwarks against such transgressions.

The Aftermath 

In the aftermath of the clashes, the police have worked tirelessly to restore calm. A young man, whose video replete with harsh and obscene language went viral, was apprehended and has since apologised for his actions. The MBVV police have also taken to social media to reassure the public that the situation is under control, urging them to avoid circulating messages that could exacerbate tensions.

The Thane district has witnessed acts of vandalism targeting shops, further escalating tensions. In response, the police have apprehended individuals linked to these acts, hoping that such measures will expedite the return of peace. Advisories have been issued, warning against the dissemination of provocative messages and rumours.

In total, 19 individuals have been taken into custody in relation to numerous incidents of violence. The Mira-Bhayandar and Vasai-Virar police have underscored their commitment to legal action against those who spread rumours through fake messages. The authorities have also highlighted the importance of brotherhood and unity, reminding citizens that above all, they are Indians first.

Conclusion 

In a world where old videos, stripped of context, can fuel tensions, the police have issued a note referring to the aforementioned fake video message. They urge citizens to exercise caution, to neither believe nor circulate such messages. Police Authorities have assured that no one involved in the violence will be spared, and peace committees are being convened to restore harmony. The Mira Road incident serves as a sign of the prowess of information and responsibility that comes with it. In the digital age, where the ephemeral and the eternal collide, we must navigate the waters of truth with care. Ultimately, it is not just the image of a locality that is at stake, but the essence of our collective humanity.

References 

• https://youtu.be/gK2Ac1qP-nE?feature=shared
• https://www.mid-day.com/mumbai/mumbai-crime-news/article/mira-road-communal-clash-those-spreading-fake-messages-to-face-strict-action-say-mira-bhayandar-vasai-virar-cops-23331572
• https://www.mid-day.com/mumbai/mumbai-news/article/mira-road-communal-clash-cybercops-on-alert-for-fake-clips-23331653
• https://www.theweek.in/wire-updates/national/2024/01/24/bom43-mh-shops-3rdld-vandalism.html

‍

The Illusion of Digital Serenity

‍

In the age of technology, our email accounts have turned into overcrowded spaces, full of newsletters, special offers, and unwanted updates. To most, the presence of an "unsubscribe" link brings a minor feeling of empowerment, a chance to declutter and restore digital serenity. Yet behind this harmless-seeming tool lurks a developing cybersecurity threat. Recent research and expert discussions indicate that the "unsubscribe" button is being used by cybercriminals to carry out phishing campaigns, confirm active email accounts, and distribute malware. This new threat not only undermines individual users but also has wider implications for trust, behaviour, and governance in cyberspace.

‍

Exploiting User Behaviour

‍

The main challenge is the manipulation of user behaviour. Cyber thieves have learned to analyse typical user habits, most notably the instinctive process of unsubscribing from spam mail. Taking advantage of this, they now place criminal codes in emails that pose as real subscription programs. These codes may redirect traffic to fake websites that attempt to steal credentials, force the installation of malicious code, or merely count the click as verification that the recipient's email address is valid. Once confirmed, these addresses tend to be resold on the dark web or included in additional spam lists, further elevating the threat of subsequent attacks.

‍

A Social Engineering Trap

‍

This type of cyber deception is a prime example of social engineering, where the weakest link in the security chain ends up being the human factor. In the same way, misinformation campaigns take advantage of cognitive biases such as confirmation or familiarity, and these unsubscribe traps exploit user convenience and habits. The bait is so simple, and that is exactly what makes it work. Someone attempting to combat spam may unknowingly walk into a sophisticated cyber threat. Unlike phishing messages impersonating banks or government agencies, which tend to elicit suspicion, spoofed unsubscribe links are integrated into regular digital habits, making them more difficult to recognise and resist.

‍

Professional Disguise, Malicious Intent

‍

Technical analysis determines that most of these messages come from suspicious domains or spoofed versions of valid ones, like "@offers-zomato.ru" in place of the authentic "@zomato.com." The appearance of the email looks professional, complete with logos and styling copied from reputable businesses. But behind the HTML styling lies redirection code and obfuscated scripts with a very different agenda. At times, users are redirected to sites that mimic login pages or questionnaire forms, capturing sensitive information under the guise of email preference management.

‍

Beyond the Inbox: Broader Consequences

‍

The consequences of this attack go beyond the individual user. The compromise of a personal email account can be used to carry out more extensive spamming campaigns, engage in botnets, or even execute identity theft. Furthermore, the compromised devices may become entry points for ransomware attacks or espionage campaigns, particularly if the individual works within sensitive sectors such as finance, defence, or healthcare. In this context, what appears to be a personal lapse becomes a national security risk. This is why the issue posed by the weaponised unsubscribe button must be considered not just as a cybersecurity risk but also as a policy and public awareness issue.

‍

Platform Responsibility

‍

Platform responsibility is yet another important aspect. Email service providers such as Gmail, Outlook, and ProtonMail do have native unsubscribe capabilities, under the List-Unsubscribe header mechanism. These tools enable users to remove themselves from valid mailing lists safely without engaging with the original email content. Yet many users do not know about these safer options and instead resort to in-body unsubscribe links that are easier to find but risky. To that extent, email platforms need to do more not only to enhance backend security but also to steer user actions through simple interfaces, safety messages, and digital hygiene alerts.

‍

Education as a Defence

‍

Education plays a central role in mitigation. Just as cyber hygiene campaigns have been launched to teach users not to click on suspicious links or download unknown attachments, similar efforts are needed to highlight the risks associated with casual unsubscribing. Cybersecurity literacy must evolve to match changing threat patterns. Rather than only targeting clearly malicious activity, awareness campaigns should start tackling deceptive tactics that disguise themselves as beneficial, including unsubscribe traps or simulated customer support conversations. Partnerships between public and private institutions might be vital in helping with this by leveraging their resources for mass digital education.

‍

Practical Safeguards for Users

‍

Users are advised to always check the sender's domain before clicking any link, avoid unknown promotional emails, and hover over any link to preview its true destination. Rather than clicking "unsubscribe," users can simply mark such emails as spam or junk so that their email providers can automatically filter similar messages in the future. For enhanced security, embracing mechanisms such as mail client sandboxing, two-factor authentication (2FA) support, and alias email addresses for sign-ups can also help create layered defences. 

Policy and Regulatory Implications

‍

Policy implications are also significant. Governments and data protection regulators must study the increasing misuse of misleading unsubscribe hyperlinks under electronic communication and consent laws. In India, the new Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 (DPDPA), provides a legislative framework to counter such deceptive practices, especially under the principles of legitimate processing and purpose limitation. The law requires that the processing of data should be transparent and fair, a requirement that malicious emails obviously breach. Regulatory agencies like CERT-In can also release periodic notifications warning users against such trends as part of their charter to encourage secure digital practices.

The Trust Deficit

‍

The vulnerability also relates to broader issues of trust in digital infrastructure. When widely used tools such as an unsubscribe feature become points of exploitation, user trust in digital platforms erodes. Such a trust deficit can lead to generalised distrust of email systems, digital communication, and even legitimate marketing. Restoring and maintaining such trust demands a unified response that includes technical measures, user education, and regulatory action.

Conclusion: Inbox Hygiene with Caution

‍

The "unsubscribe button trap" is a parable of the modern age. It illustrates how mundane digital interactions, when manipulated, can do great damage not only to individual users but also to the larger ecosystem of online security and trust. As cyber-attacks grow increasingly psychologically advanced and behaviorally focused, our response must similarly become more sophisticated, interdisciplinary, and user-driven. Getting your inbox in order should never involve putting yourself in cyber danger. But as things stand, even that basic task requires caution, context, and clear thinking.

‍